The neuronal projections that stop social animals like us from acting out instinctual impulses have been traced by scientists at European Molecular Biology Laboratory (EMBL).
Cornelius Gross, who led the work at EMBL, said:
“Instincts like fear and sex are important, but you don’t want to be acting on them all the time. We need to be able to dynamically control our instinctive behaviours, depending on the situation."
From fighting the urge to hit someone to resisting the temptation to run off stage instead of giving a public speech, we are often confronted with situations where we have to control our instincts.
Brainstem vs. Prefrontal Cortex
The driver of our instincts is the brainstem - the region at the very base of your brain, just above the spinal chord. Scientists have known for some time that another brain region, the prefrontal cortex, plays a role in keeping those instincts in check.
But exactly how the prefrontal cortex puts a break on the brainstem has remained unclear.
Gross and colleagues have now literally found the connection between prefrontal cortex and brainstem. The EMBL scientists teamed up with Tiago Branco’s lab at MRC LMB, and traced connections between neurons in a mouse brain.
They discovered that the prefrontal cortex makes prominent connections directly to the brainstem.
The researchers went on to confirm that this physical connection was the brake that inhibits instinctive behavior. They found that in mice that have been repeatedly defeated by another mouse (the murine equivalent to being bullied) this connection weakens, and the mice act more scared.
The scientists found that they could elicit those same fearful behaviors in mice that had never been bullied, simply by using drugs to block the connection between prefrontal cortex and brainstem.
These findings provide an anatomical explanation for why it’s much easier to stop yourself from hitting someone than it is to stop yourself from feeling aggressive. The scientists found that the connection from the prefrontal cortex is to a very specific region of the brainstem, called the periaqueductal gray (PAG), which is responsible for the acting out of our instincts.
However, it doesn’t affect the hypothalamus, the region that controls feelings and emotions. So the prefrontal cortex keeps behaviour in check, but doesn’t affect the underlying instinctive feeling: it stops you from running off-stage, but doesn’t abate the butterflies in your stomach.
“One fascinating implication we’re looking at now is that we know the pre-frontal cortex matures during adolescence. Kids are really bad at inhibiting their instincts; they don’t have this control,” says Gross, “so we’re trying to figure out how this inhibition comes about, especially as many mental illnesses like mood disorders are typically adult-onset."
Phineas Gage Strikes Again
The story of Phineas Gage is a staple in neuroscience textbooks. In 1848, while he was packing explosives into a rock to clear the way for a railroad, a premature explosion shot a metal rod through Gage’s head.
Remarkably, he survived. But his personality appears to have changed - although accounts and interpretations vary over what exactly the changes were, and how long they lasted.
Nevertheless, Gage’s case was instrumental in proving that there was a connection between brain and personality. Exactly which parts of Gage’s brain were damaged has also been the subject of intense debate.
The frontal lobes of his brain were certainly affected, and computer-based reconstructions of Gage’s injury, as well as studies of other patients - injured in accidents or by stroke - have pointed to the prefrontal cortex as a likely seat for our inhibitions.
A study of people trying to avoid injury - albeit in a simulated environment - hinted at how that inhibition might come about.
Looking at the brains of people as they played a Pac-man-like game in an MRI scanner, scientists found that while players were ‘running away’ from ‘Pac-man’, their pre-frontal cortex was active, but in the moments just before their character was eaten, players' pre-frontal cortex would shut down and a region of the brainstem called the periaqueductal gray became active.
This study suggested a link between those two brain regions, and inspired Gross and colleagues to investigate.
Tamara B Franklin, Bianca A Silva, Zina Perova, Livia Marrone, Maria E Masferrer, Yang Zhan, Angie Kaplan, Louise Greetham, Violaine Verrechia, Andreas Halman, Sara Pagella, Alexei L Vyssotski, Anna Illarionova, Valery Grinevich, Tiago Branco & Cornelius T Gross Prefrontal cortical control of a brainstem social behavior circuit Nature Neuroscience (2017) doi:10.1038/nn.4470
Image: Prefrontal cortical neurons labeled in purple directly project to the PAG and control our instinctive behaviours. IMAGE: EMBL/Livia Marrone