Thinking About The Big Picture Helps Turn Criticism Into Positive Action


Criticism can be hurtful, but thinking about the bigger picture may help transmute criticism into positive change, suggests new research.

Lead researcher Jennifer Belding, Ph.D., from Ohio State University, said:

“People are defensive when they are told about something they did wrong. Listening to negative feedback requires self-control because you have to get past the fact that hearing it hurts and instead use the information to improve over time.”

With three experiments, researchers found that people were more apt to receive criticism and make steps toward changing their behaviour if they took a broad “forest instead of the trees” view and believed that change was possible.

Narrow vs. Broad Thinking

For the first experiment, 85 undergraduate students at Ohio State University (47 female, 38 male) were randomly divided into two groups with one group encouraged to think in a broad view, which is known as high-level construal.

They were asked to name a category for 20 different objects. For example, these participants would say that a soda is a type of drink.

The other group was encouraged to think in a narrow view, or low-level construal, by picking a specific example for each object. These participants might have said that an example of a soda is a Coke.

After reading about the dangers of skin cancer and tanning, participants were asked if they were motivated to reduce their risk by using sunblock and other means. Participants who enjoyed tanning were more motivated to change their behaviour if they had been encouraged to think in a broad perspective.

People also need to believe change is possible to motivate them to alter their behaviour, according to the findings of a second experiment with 133 undergraduate students including 58 female, 72 male, and three unrecorded participants.

One group read a message that said sunblock and staying out of the sun could help prevent skin cancer, while the other group was told that things like genetics and ethnicity caused skin cancer.

When participants were given the option to read about skin cancer prevention tips, participants with a family history of skin cancer spent more time reading the materials if they had been told that skin cancer was preventable.

Practical Implications

Two additional experiments conducted online with more than 600 participants had similar results. People who tanned were more motivated to seek information about skin cancer prevention tips if they had been encouraged to think in a broad view and if they believed skin cancer could be prevented.

“Thinking about the big picture is going to make people more open to negative feedback when it’s something you can and should improve,”

Belding said.

The research findings have practical implications. When delivering negative feedback to an employee, a supervisor should speak broadly about why these improvements are needed and possible before addressing specific steps, Belding said.

She added that screaming and blaming never helps because it makes employees more defensive and less likely to change their behaviour.

In a similar vein, health education campaigns should focus on the large picture and inform people that change is possible to motivate action, Belding said.

Belding, J.; Naufel, K.; and Fujita, K. (2015). Using High-Level Construal and Perceptions of Changeability to Promote Self-Change Over Self-Protection Motives in Response to Negative Feedback. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 41(6).

Last Updated on December 29, 2022