Vicarious traumatization refers to the transformation in a helper’s inner experience resulting from empathetic engagement with trauma survivors. It differs from burnout or compassion fatigue by specifically altering one’s cognitive schemas and belief systems.
Irene Lisa McCann and Laurie Anne Pearlman coined the phrase vicarious trauma (VT). The phenomenon is also known as secondary traumatic stress, a term coined by trauma researcher Charles Figley.
This phenomenon can affect various professionals, including therapists, social workers, and first responders. The changes are cumulative and pervasive, potentially impacting personal and professional relationships.
Vicarious trauma is not a sign of weakness or incompetence. Rather, it’s a natural consequence of engaging empathetically with traumatic material over time.
Theorists argue on vicarious trauma, with some claiming it is based on the concepts of countertransference and compassion fatigue. According to McCann and Pearlman, these concepts are likely related, but vicarious trauma is separate. Understanding of the phenomenon is developing.
Symptoms, Causes and Triggers
Anything that impairs a helper’s capacity to carry out his or her responsibilities to aid traumatized clients can contribute to vicarious trauma. Many human-service personnel indicate that administrative and bureaucratic barriers impeding their performance influence work satisfaction.
Several factors contribute to the development of vicarious traumatization:
Repeated exposure to traumatic narratives
Empathetic engagement with trauma survivors
Personal history of trauma
High caseloads of trauma-related work
Lack of organizational support or resources
Specific triggers may include:
Graphic descriptions or images of traumatic events
Working with particularly vulnerable populations (e.g., children)
Cases that resonate with personal experiences
Unexpected or sudden traumatic incidents in clients’ lives
The intensity and frequency of exposure play crucial roles in the development of vicarious trauma.
Symptoms of Vicarious Trauma
Vicarious traumatization can manifest in various ways, affecting cognitive, emotional, and behavioral aspects of an individual’s life:
Cognitive symptoms:
- Intrusive thoughts about clients’ traumas
- Difficulty concentrating
- Changes in worldview or belief systems
Emotional symptoms:
- Heightened anxiety or fear
- Emotional numbness or detachment
- Increased irritability or anger
Behavioral symptoms:
- Social withdrawal
- Sleep disturbances
- Increased use of alcohol or substances
Physical symptoms may also occur, such as headaches, fatigue, or gastrointestinal issues. These symptoms can significantly impact both personal and professional life if left unaddressed.
Difference Between Vicarious Trauma and Secondary Trauma
While often used interchangeably, vicarious trauma and secondary trauma have distinct characteristics:
Vicarious Trauma:
- Cumulative effect over time
- Involves changes in cognitive schemas and worldview
- Results from empathetic engagement with multiple trauma survivors
Secondary Trauma:
- Can occur after a single exposure
- Mimics symptoms of PTSD
- Often results from direct exposure to a traumatic event or detailed account
Both can lead to similar symptoms, but vicarious trauma is more about the gradual, transformative impact on one’s beliefs and perceptions. Secondary trauma, in contrast, is a more immediate stress response to specific traumatic information or events.
Prevalence in Helping Professions
Therapists and counselors face high rates of vicarious traumatization. Studies show that 50-70% of mental health professionals experience symptoms at some point in their careers. Psychologists working with trauma survivors are particularly vulnerable.
Cognitive changes, such as altered worldviews and diminished sense of safety, are common. Emotional exhaustion and burnout often accompany these shifts. Many professionals report difficulty maintaining boundaries between work and personal life.
Regular exposure to clients’ traumatic narratives can lead to intrusive thoughts and nightmares. Some therapists develop avoidance behaviors or hypervigilance similar to PTSD symptoms.
Social workers often bear witness to clients’ trauma, abuse, and hardship. This emotional load can lead to secondary traumatic stress.
Research indicates that 15-32% of social workers experience high levels of vicarious trauma. Those working in child welfare and domestic violence settings are particularly affected.
Compassion fatigue is common, impacting job satisfaction and retention rates. Many social workers report feeling overwhelmed by their clients’ needs. Some develop physical symptoms like headaches or gastrointestinal issues.
Police officers, firefighters, and emergency medical personnel also frequently encounter traumatic scenes. This puts them at elevated risk for vicarious traumatization.
Many first responders struggle with sleep disturbances and irritability. Substance abuse rates are higher in this population compared to the general public. Some develop a sense of detachment or emotional numbing as a coping mechanism.
Measurement
Vicarious trauma is a complex construct that necessitates a multifaceted assessment. Self-capacities, ego resources, frame of reference (identity, worldview, and spirituality), psychological needs, and trauma symptoms are all aspects of VT that must be examined for a complete assessment.
It may be measured in a variety of ways, including:
- Self-capacities, using the Inner Experience Questionnaire or the Inventory of Altered Self-Capacities
- Psychological needs, using the Trauma and Attachment Belief Scale
- Trauma symptoms, using the PTSD Checklist, Impact of Events Scale, Impact of Events Scale-Revised, or Trauma Symptom Inventory
- The Professional Quality of Life (ProQol) version five
- Secondary Traumatic Stress Scale
The Secondary Traumatic Stress Scale (STSS) is a widely used instrument for evaluating secondary traumatic stress. It consists of 17 items that measure intrusion, avoidance, and arousal symptoms.
The STSS uses a 5-point Likert scale, ranging from “never” to “very often”. Higher scores indicate greater levels of secondary traumatic stress.
This tool helps professionals identify early signs of vicarious trauma. It can be used in various settings, including healthcare, social work, and law enforcement. Regular use of the STSS allows organizations to monitor their staff’s well-being and implement timely interventions when needed.
Physical and Psychological Manifestations
Vicarious traumatization can significantly affect cognitive and emotional functioning. Individuals may experience intrusive thoughts related to traumatic events they’ve been exposed to secondhand. This can lead to heightened anxiety and difficulty concentrating.
Depression and sadness are common emotional responses. Professionals may find themselves struggling with persistent low mood and a sense of hopelessness. Mood swings and irritability can also become more frequent.
Hypervigilance is another key symptom. Those affected may become overly alert to potential threats in their environment, even in safe situations. This state of constant alertness can be mentally exhausting.
Behavioral Changes
Behavioral shifts often accompany vicarious traumatization. Sleep problems are frequently reported, with individuals experiencing difficulty falling asleep or staying asleep through the night. This can lead to fatigue and decreased work performance.
Social withdrawal is another common behavioral change. Professionals may isolate themselves from friends, family, or colleagues as a coping mechanism. This isolation can further exacerbate emotional distress.
Changes in appetite and exercise habits may also occur. Some individuals might turn to unhealthy coping mechanisms, such as increased alcohol consumption or overeating, to manage their stress.
Long-Term Health Implications
The long-term effects of vicarious traumatization can be significant if left unaddressed. Chronic stress from repeated exposure to traumatic content can lead to physical health problems. These may include headaches, gastrointestinal issues, and weakened immune function.
Cardiovascular health can also be impacted. Prolonged stress may contribute to high blood pressure and an increased risk of heart disease. Musculoskeletal issues, such as chronic pain or tension, are not uncommon.
Mental health consequences can be severe. If left untreated, vicarious traumatization can develop into more serious conditions like PTSD or clinical depression. This underscores the importance of early intervention and self-care strategies.
Intervention and Therapy Options
Therapists specializing in trauma play a crucial role in treating vicarious traumatization. They help individuals process their experiences and develop healthier thought patterns. Cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) is often employed to identify and modify negative beliefs stemming from indirect trauma exposure.
Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing (EMDR) has shown promise in addressing trauma-related symptoms. This therapy helps reprocess distressing memories and reduce their emotional impact.
Group therapy sessions provide a supportive environment where individuals can share experiences and learn from others facing similar challenges. These sessions foster a sense of community and reduce feelings of isolation.
Coping Strategies and Techniques
Developing effective coping mechanisms is essential for managing vicarious trauma. Mindfulness practices, such as meditation and deep breathing exercises, help individuals stay grounded in the present moment and reduce anxiety.
Regular physical exercise releases endorphins and improves overall mental well-being. Activities like yoga or tai chi combine physical movement with mindfulness, offering dual benefits.
Establishing clear boundaries between work and personal life is crucial. This may include:
- Limiting exposure to traumatic content
- Taking regular breaks during work hours
- Engaging in enjoyable non-work-related activities
Journaling provides an outlet for processing emotions and gaining perspective on challenging experiences.
Resilience Training and Support Programs
Structured resilience training programs equip individuals with skills to navigate vicarious trauma effectively. These programs often focus on:
- Emotional regulation techniques
- Stress management skills
- Building a strong support network
Peer support groups offer a valuable platform for sharing experiences and coping strategies. Regular meetings provide ongoing encouragement and validation.
Workplace initiatives that prioritize employee well-being can significantly impact resilience. These may include flexible scheduling options, access to mental health resources, and regular debriefing sessions
Ongoing professional development opportunities help individuals stay informed about the latest research and best practices in managing vicarious trauma, empowering them to take proactive steps in their self-care.
Role of Personal Self-Care
Personal self-care plays a crucial role in mitigating vicarious traumatization. It involves setting boundaries, fostering self-efficacy, and practicing mindfulness techniques to maintain mental and emotional well-being.
Setting clear boundaries is essential for professionals working with trauma survivors. This involves separating work from personal life and learning to say no when necessary. Effective boundary-setting helps prevent emotional exhaustion and maintains a healthy work-life balance.
Professionals should limit exposure to traumatic material outside of work hours. This may include avoiding graphic news stories or intense media content during personal time.
Creating a support network of colleagues and supervisors can provide a safe space to discuss challenging cases without breaching confidentiality. Regular debriefing sessions help process difficult emotions and experiences.
Developing a strong sense of self-efficacy involves recognizing one’s ability to cope with challenging situations and maintaining a sense of control over work-related stressors.
Professionals can enhance self-efficacy by:
- Setting realistic goals and expectations
- Celebrating small successes and progress
- Seeking ongoing education and skill development
- Engaging in regular self-reflection and assessment
Incorporating mindfulness and relaxation techniques into daily routines can significantly reduce stress. These practices help professionals stay grounded and present, even when dealing with intense emotional content.
Effective mindfulness strategies include:
- Deep breathing exercises
- Progressive muscle relaxation
- Guided imagery
- Meditation
Regular practice of these techniques can improve compassion satisfaction and reduce secondary traumatic stress symptoms. Even brief moments of mindfulness throughout the day can have a positive impact on well-being.
References:
- Bell, Holly & Kulkarni, Shanti & Dalton, Lisa. (2003) Organizational Prevention of Vicarious Trauma. Families in Society: The Journal of Contemporary Social Services. 84. 463-470. 10.1606/1044-3894.131
- Bober, T., & Regehr, C. (2006). Strategies for reducing secondary or vicarious trauma: Do they work? Brief Treatment and Crisis Intervention, 6(1), 1–9
- Butler, Lisa D et al. (2017) Trauma, stress, and self-care in clinical training: Predictors of burnout, decline in health status, secondary traumatic stress symptoms, and compassion satisfaction. Psychological trauma : theory, research, practice and policy vol. 9,4 416-424. doi:10.1037/tra0000187
- Canfield, J. (2005). Secondary Traumatization, Burnout, and Vicarious Traumatization: A Review of the Literature as It Relates to Therapists Who Treat Trauma. Smith College Studies in Social Work, 75(2), 81–101.
- Janoff-Bulman, Ronnie (1 June 1989) Assumptive Worlds and the Stress of Traumatic Events: Applications of the Schema Construct. Social Cognition. 7 (2): 113–136. doi:10.1521/soco.1989.7.2.113
- Lerias, D. and Byrne, M.K. (2003) Vicarious traumatization: symptoms and predictors. Stress and Health, 19: 129-138. do: 10.1002/smi.969
- Meadors, Patrick; Lamson, Angela (1 January 2008) Compassion Fatigue and Secondary Traumatization: Provider Self Care on Intensive Care Units for Children. Journal of Pediatric Health Care. 22 (1): 24–34. doi:10.1016/j.pedhc.2007.01.006
- Norcross, John C.; Guy, James D. (25 June 2007). Leaving It at the Office: A Guide to Psychotherapist Self-Care. Guilford Press. ISBN 978-1-59385-576-5
- Pearlman, Laurie A (2003) Trauma and Attachment Belief Scale Manual. Los Angeles: Western Psychological Services. OCLC 828744792
- Tabor, Pamela Diane. Vicarious traumatization: Concept analysis. Journal of Forensic Nursing 7(4):p 203-208, December 2011. DOI: 10.1111/j.1939-3938.2011.01115.x