Serotonin promotes active persistence in a task, even in the face of uncertain reward, new research shows.
Previous results have suggested that increased serotonin levels make animals (including people) more willing to wait for a reward — in other words, it was believed to increase patience. This was compatible with the idea that serotonin generally acts by inhibiting behavior, because in many cases, patience requires postponing an action.
Now, this idea has been challenged by an international team led by neuroscientists from the Champalimaud Centre for the Unknown (CCU), in Lisbon, Portugal, in this study.
Serotonin has multiple functions in the brain, and its effects are not completely understood. Serotonin is at the root of a whole class of antidepressant drugs, the most well-known of which is Prozac, that seem to work by increasing serotonin levels in the human brain.
Persistence means actively following through on a task like completing homework, whereas many forms of patience require sitting tight and doing nothing. It so happens that the tasks used in the previous studies did not allow their authors to distinguish between patience and persistence.
But in the new work, Eran Lottem, the first author of the paper, and his colleagues developed a task that is actually very similar to the natural situation animals face when foraging for food.
“We had some hints suggesting that the inhibitory effect of serotonin was not general. Some behaviors were unaffected by serotonin. But we had never seen an active behavior promoted by serotonin. This is, to my knowledge, the first time such a behavior has been observed when serotonin-producing neurons are activated,"
The mice were presented with the choice of two drinking sites placed at each end of a long rectangular box. At any given time, only one drinking site was ready to release water, so the mice had to roam back and forth between the two sides of the box to find the water, and to get it, they had to give a poke with their nose at the drinking site.
[caption id=“attachment_94732” align=“aligncenter” width=“680”] The probabilistic foraging task.
Credit: Eran Lottem et al, CC-BY[/caption]
To mimic the unpredictability of real world situations, the experimenters arranged the experiment such that even an active drinking site did not always deliver water, so they would have to tolerate some unsuccessful pokes. This provided the scientists with a way to measure the persistence of the animals — they could count the number of pokes the mice were willing to give in order to try to get water at a “dry” site.
The scientists used a technology known as optogenetics to stimulate the serotonin-producing neurons using pulses of laser light delivered by an implanted optic fiber to the animals' brains.
“What we saw was that when those neurons were stimulated, the animals were willing to poke longer even when they were not getting water”, says Lottem. “Therefore, serotonin was not inhibiting their behavior because, in that case, the mice would have given up sooner."
In other words, activating serotonin neurons promotes active persistence rather than just plain old patience.
The results may lead to better treatments for depression, a disorder in which serotonin is implicated.
“The difference between patience and persistence may sound subtle, but the implication is not: it could be the difference between quietly sitting in bed while the world goes by and jumping out of bed each day to greet it,"
Zachary Mainen, the lead author of this study, said.
The research was supported by the European Research Council and Champalimaud Foundation.
Eran Lottem, Dhruba Banerjee, Pietro Vertechi, Dario Sarra, Matthijs oude Lohuis & Zachary F. Mainen Activation of serotonin neurons promotes active persistence in a probabilistic foraging task Nature Communications volume 9, Article number: 1000 (2018) doi:10.1038/s41467-018-03438-y
Top Image: Champalimaud Centre for the Unknown/Sara Matias