Odor may alter the organization of relevant or fearful memories so that they are delayed in the de-contextualization process that occurs across time, suggests research from Boston University.
Until now, the scent-memory connection has been something of an enigma. In fact, even the mechanisms that underlie memory formation in general have been debated in recent years.
The traditional theory — systems consolidation theory — suggests that our memories start out being processed by a small, horseshoe-shaped brain area called the hippocampus, which infuses them with rich details. Over time, especially when we sleep, the set of brain cells that holds onto a particular memory reactivates and reorganizes.
The memory then becomes processed by the front of the brain — the prefrontal cortex — instead of the hippocampus, and many of the details become lost in the shuffle.
The Power Of Common Scents
We’ve all experienced the strange memory-jogging power of scents. Perhaps the aroma of fresh pine brings you back to your childhood Christmases, or your heart starts to race when you step into a doctor’s office and the sharp odor of disinfectant fills your nose.
Now, researchers from Boston University’s Center for Systems Neuroscience reveal just how much power scents have in triggering the memory of past experiences — and the potential for odor to be used as a tool to treat memory-related mood disorders.
“If odor could be used to elicit the rich recollection of a memory—even of a traumatic experience — we could take advantage of that [therapeutically],"
says BU neuroscientist Steve Ramirez, the senior author of a new paper describing his team’s findings.
Systems Consolidation Theory
The systems consolidation theory does have its merits. For starters, it would explain why our memories tend to get a bit fuzzy as time passes.
It also helps explain why people with hippocampal damage are often unable to form new memories while their ability to keep old, prefrontal cortex-stored memories remains perfectly intact. In contrast, those with prefrontal cortex damage often exhibit the flavor of amnesia we often see in soap operas: an inability to remember the past.
However, critics of the systems consolidation theory maintain that it doesn’t tell the whole story.
If memories slip out of the hippocampus and become stripped of their details over time, then why do many people retain vivid recollections of an event even years later— particularly people with post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD)? And why do scents, which are processed in the hippocampus, sometimes trigger seemingly dormant memories?
A Cue To Reinvigorate
To answer these questions, Ramirez and members of his lab created fear memories in mice by giving them a series of harmless but startling electric shocks inside a special container. During the shocks, half of the mice were exposed to the scent of almond extract, while the other half were not exposed to any scent.
The next day, the researchers returned the mice to the same container to prompt them to recall their newly formed memories. Once again, the mice in the odor group got a whiff of almond extract during their session, while the no-odor group was not exposed to any scent.
But this time, neither group received any new electric shocks. Consistent with the systems consolidation theory, both groups exhibited significant activation of the hippocampus during this early recall session, indicating they remembered receiving the shocks from the day before.
However, during the next recall session 20 days later, the researchers were in for a shock of their own. As expected, in the no-odor group, processing of the fear memory had shifted to the prefrontal cortex — but the odor group still had significant brain activity in the hippocampus.
“[This finding suggests] that we can bias the hippocampus to come back online at a timepoint when we wouldn’t expect it to be online anymore because the memory is too old. Odor can act as a cue to reinvigorate or reenergize that memory with detail,"
Ramirez adds that we still aren’t sure about odor’s exact role in memory processing. Perhaps odors delay a memory’s shift to relying on the prefrontal cortex, thereby preserving the details for longer.
If this is the case, an odor needs only to be present during memory formation for a memory to retain its vividness. Alternatively, it’s possible that the prefrontal-cortex shift still occurs in an odor-associated memory, but that if the same odor emerges again later on, the hippocampus becomes reactivated and the memory regains the details it had lost.
Regardless of the specifics, Ramirez says that this research provides us with a “blueprint” of memory processing in nonhuman animals, and this information might one day lead to breakthroughs in the treatment of mental health conditions in humans, such as PTSD.
Many psychotherapy– and drug-based treatments for PTSD involve trying to suppress or dampen traumatic memories, but this process can only be carried out effectively when people actively recall the memories first.
“Now that we know that odor can shift memories to become more hippocampus dependent, we could potentially develop strategies that engage or disengage the hippocampus. And then we could integrate some behavioral or drug-based approaches to bring the hippocampus back offline if our goal is to permanently suppress a fear memory,"
In other words, the scents that spark our memories may be more powerful than we realize. Today, they serve as the triggers for our nostalgia and our anxiety — but tomorrow, they could be our treatments.
“We can potentially view memory as its own kind of drug—as an antidepressant or anxiety reducer. And [odor] could be an experimentally controllable factor that we could deliver to people. It may be a very powerful tool,"
 Stephanie L. Grella, Amanda H. Fortin, Olivia McKissick, Heloise Leblanc and Steve Ramirez. Odor modulates the temporal dynamics of fear memory consolidation. Learn. Mem. 2020. 27: 150-163