People with balance disorders or dizziness traceable to an inner-ear disturbance show distinctive abnormal eye movements when the affected ear is exposed to the strong pull of an MRI’s magnetic field, Johns Hopkins researchers have found.
The researchers first reported in 2011 that an MRI’s magnetic field pushes on the inner ear fluid responsible for maintaining balance, causing subjects undergoing MRI scans to have jerky eye movements and dizziness.
Two new studies now suggest that these strong magnets could be used to diagnose, treat and study inner ear disorders in the future, replacing more invasive and uncomfortable examinations.
Tracking Eye Movements
In the first study a team led by Bryan Ward, M.D., a resident in the Department of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery at the Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, placed nine patients with balance problems in an MRI machine and took video of their eye movements, without taking any MRI images.
The earlier research had shown that healthy volunteers subjected to a 7 Tesla magnetic field (the strength of the most modern MRI machine) experienced a characteristic eye movement called nystagmus, in which the eyes repeatedly drift to one side and then jerk back.
This time, the researchers were curious whether this movement might look different in patients with inner ear problems, whose semicircular canals (the fluid-filled spaces inside the ear that are responsible for maintaining balance) would likely react differently to the MRI magnet’s pull.
While healthy, normal volunteers' eyes moved side to side when in the MRI, with the direction of movement dependent on whether they entered the MRI tunnel head or feet first, people with “one-sided” inner ear problems displayed different eye movements that depended on which ear was affected.
For example, Ward says, the eyes of patients whose left ear was affected drifted down and jerked up when put into the MRI tunnel head first. Those whose right ear was affected had an opposite movement. Both sets of patients showed patterns of rapid eye motions not seen in the healthy volunteers.
More Comfortable Diagnosis
Because the abnormal findings consistently showed which ear was affected in the patients, Ward says, researchers may eventually be able to use magnetic stimulation to diagnose the cause of balance disorders.
Currently, people whose dizziness or imbalance is suspected to originate in the inner ear may have eye movements measured after being spun around in a chair, tilted backward on special tables, or subjected to sometimes uncomfortable ear canal irrigation with cold or warm water.
Magnetic stimulation, acting as a virtual reality stimulator, could also offer an alternative to traditional physical therapy for balance disorders, which often involve rapid head movements that make patients dizzy.
“Using magnetic stimulation, perhaps in a portable device that could fit in a doctor’s office, could offer an alternative that’s more comfortable,” Ward says.
Zebrafish and Human Vestibular System
In a second study, Ward and his colleagues set out to investigate whether the inner ear balance systems of zebrafish are also influenced by magnetic stimulation. Zebrafish are a popular model for genetics and pharmaceutical studies of hearing and balance because of their surprising anatomical similarity to humans' vestibular systems, Ward says.
If the inner ears of these fish were also affected by a strong magnet’s pull, he says, these animals could eventually be a useful tool for studying which genes are involved in inherited inner ear balance problems or which drugs could be used to treat these disorders.
To investigate, the researchers placed 30 healthy zebrafish, one at a time, into a very strong 11.7 Tesla magnetic field, using a smaller MRI machine to better accommodate the aquarium used to hold each fish.
When the aquarium was in the magnetic field, the majority of fish responded in a dramatic way akin to the vertigo and imbalance that humans with inner ear system disturbances show: The fish flipped, rolled and swam faster than normal.
The fish reverted to normal swimming behavior only when their aquarium was taken out of the MRI machine and away from the magnet.
To make sure this behavior wasn’t due to any vision changes or effects on the lateral line (an organ on the side of the body of a fish important for helping the animals maintain posture or sense electrical currents in the water) the researchers turned lights on and off every 30 seconds while the fish were in the magnetic field and also had them swim in the magnetic field after they’d been exposed to gentamicin, an antibiotic that kills off lateral line cells.
Neither experiment changed the animals' odd swimming behavior in the magnetic field.
The researchers further observed that individual fish seemed to be affected by the orientation of the magnetic field, swimming preferentially either in the direction of the magnetic field or in an opposite orientation. For example, some of the animals preferred to swim north-south in a north-south field, while others preferred to swim east-west.
Putting the animals into an opposing field didn’t affect their preference. These results could add insight into the scientific field of magnetosensation, which studies how some animals are able to sense Earth’s magnetic field and use it for purposes such as migration, Ward says.
Overall, he adds, the findings in humans and fish could eventually lead to useful ways to harness the effect of an MRI magnet on the inner ear.
“We may someday have some practical applications for this anatomical oddity,” Ward says.
Bryan K. Ward, Dale C. Roberts, Charles C. Della Santina, John P. Carey, David S. Zee. Magnetic Vestibular Stimulation in Subjects with Unilateral Labyrinthine Disorders. Frontiers in Neurology, 2014; 5 DOI: 10.3389/fneur.2014.00028
Photo: liz west/flickr