Twelve-month-olds recognize that speech in a language not their own is used for communication, a new study has found. The results offer new insights into how language is processed at a young age.
“By their first birthday, babies understand that foreign languages can communicate information between people, even though the babies themselves don’t understand the foreign language. This tells us that infants’ processing of formal aspects of language, such as speech sounds and word learning, is separate from infants’ processing of communicative aspects of language—specifically, the transferring of information,”
explains Athena Vouloumanos, an associate professor in NYU’s Department of Psychology and the author of the study.
It has long been known that infants understand that speech in their native language allows speakers to communicate. Less clear is whether or not this understanding limited to their native language — does it extend to non-native languages with which infants have no experience?
To address this question, Vouloumanos conducted a series of experiments in which 12-month-old infants viewed human actors communicating in multiple ways.
The infants’ responses — i.e., their gaze — were recorded by an observer. Gaze length is a commonly used measurement for spotting infants’ comprehension of language and concepts.
In the experiments, the infants saw an actor, the Communicator, repeatedly select one of two objects.
When the Communicator could no longer reach the target but a second player, a Recipient, could, the Communicator vocalized a nonsense phrase either in English (infants’ native language), Spanish (rhythmically different), or Russian (structurally different), or hummed (a non-speech vocalization). The infants had not been exposed to Spanish or Russian before.
Across all three languages, native and non-native, but not humming, infants looked longer when the Recipient gave the Communicator the non-target compared to the target object. By contrast, when the Communicator hummed, infants looked equally at the non-target and target outcomes.
By looking longer when the Recipient handed over the non-target object, the infants seemed to recognize that a miscommunication had taken place or that the verbal interaction had some communicative value — even if it wasn’t in their native language.
“These results indicate that infants can generalize beyond their specific experience with their own native language to recognize that all languages can allow people to communicate. By 12 months, infants do not readily map non-native words to objects or discriminate most non-native speech contrasts, but they can understand that non-native languages can transfer information to others,”
Voulez-vous jouer avec moi? Twelve-month-olds understand that foreign languages can communicate
Cognition Volume 173, April 2018, Pages 87–92