Depression has different effects on the brain activity of teenage male and female patients in certain brain regions, researchers in the UK have found.
Men and women appear to suffer from depression differently, and this is particularly striking in adolescents. By 15 years of age, girls are twice as likely to suffer from depression as boys.
There are various possible reasons for this, including body image issues, hormonal fluctuations and genetic factors, where girls are more at risk of inheriting depression. However, differences between the sexes don’t just involve the risk of experiencing depression, but also how the disorder manifests and its consequences.
“Men are more liable to suffer from persistent depression, whereas in women depression tends to be more episodic. Compared with women, depressed men are also more likely to suffer serious consequences from their depression, such as substance abuse and suicide."
explains Jie-Yu Chuang, a researcher at the University of Cambridge, and an author on the study. Despite this, so far, most researchers have focused on depression in women, likely because it is more common.
Different Brain Activity
So Chuang and her colleagues decided to carry out this latest study to find differences between depressed men and women.
They recruited adolescent volunteers for the study, who were aged between 11 and 18 years. This included 82 female and 24 male patients who suffered from depression, and 24 female and 10 male healthy volunteers.
The researchers imaged the adolescents' brains using magnetic resonance imaging, while flashing happy, sad or neutral words on a screen in a specific order.
The volunteers pressed a button when certain types of words appeared and did not press the button when others appeared, and the researchers measured their brain activity throughout the experiment. When the researchers flashed certain combinations of words on the screen, they noticed that depression affects brain activity differently between boys and girls in brain regions such as the supramarginal gyrus and posterior cingulate.
What Do The Results Mean?
“Our finding suggests that early in adolescence, depression might affect the brain differently between boys and girls,” explains Chuang. “Sex-specific treatment and prevention strategies for depression should be considered early in adolescence. Hopefully, these early interventions could alter the disease trajectory before things get worse."
The brain regions highlighted in the study have been previously linked to depression, but further work is needed to understand why they are affected differently in depressed boys, and if this is related to how boys experience and handle depression.
[caption id=“attachment_91340” align=“aligncenter” width=“680”] Significant brain activation responding to the sad distractor contrast in the male adolescents.
Significant mean activation (A–D) and significant case–control difference of these mean activation regions (E).
A box plot showed higher brain activation (extracted percent signal change) in the male controls’ cerebellum when compared with the male patients.[/caption]
Because depression is more common in girls, the researchers were not able to recruit as many boys in this study, and future experiments should compare similar numbers of girls and boys for more representative results. Chuang and her colleagues would like to explore this phenomenon further.
“I think it would be great to conduct a large longitudinal study addressing sex differences in depression from adolescence to adulthood."
The study was funded by the Medical Research Council. The IMPACT clinical trial was funded by the NHS Health Technology Assessment (HTA) Programme, Central Manchester and Manchester Children’s University Hospitals NHS Trust, and the Cambridge and Peterborough Mental Health Trust.
Jie-Yu Chuang et al Adolescent Major Depressive Disorder: Neuroimaging Evidence of Sex Difference during an Affective Go/No-Go Task Frontiers in Psychiatry (2017). DOI: 10.3389/fpsyt.2017.00119
Top Image: Steve Snodgrass/Flickr