A schizophrenia patient’s own perceptions of their experiences, and confidence in their judgments, might be factors that can help them overcome challenges to get the life they wish, suggests a new study from researchers at Penn Medicine’s Aaron T. Beck Psychopathology Research Center.
The findings counter a commonly-held belief about the relationship between so-called “cognitive insight” and neurocognitive performance (behavioral measures of attention, memory, etc.) that have important implications for treating the disorder.
Cognitive insight, measured using the Beck Cognitive Insight Scale, tested individual’s self-reflectiveness and confidence in their interpretations of experiences. Participants were asked to rate statements, such as “I have jumped to conclusions too fast,” on a scale from (0) “do not agree at all” to (4) “completely agree.”
Neurocognitive performance was assessed with the University of Pennsylvania Computerized Neurocognitive Battery that uses a series of behavioral tasks.
In two separate, prospective studies involving a total of 228 participants diagnosed with schizophrenia or schizoaffective disorder, researchers found that cognitive insight is a significant predictor of neurocognition (and not vice versa, which previous studies have suggested). For example, lower self-reflectiveness and greater overconfidence in judgments (low cognitive insight) are more likely to result in poorer neurocognition in the future.
Similarly, improvement in self-reflectiveness and overconfidence predict improved neurocognitive performance in the future. These results suggest that improving cognitive insight may directly improve performances on laboratory and real-world tasks, the authors suggest.
“The relationship between the two is important because it presents a promising opportunity to improve outcomes for individuals diagnosed with schizophrenia, many of whom experience long periods of disability, not to mention the 1.5 million new people who are diagnosed with schizophrenia worldwide every year,"
said Paul M. Grant, PhD, senior author of the study.
Recovery-oriented Cognitive Therapy
Grant, a research assistant professor of Psychology in the department of Psychiatry in the Perelman School of Medicine at the University of Pennsylvania, added:
“There’s a lot of effort in the schizophrenia field to help people through what’s called cognitive remediation, which is basically a bottom-up process of learning, memory and attention. But we think that having interventions that target positive and negative beliefs, along with goals, would be key in terms of helping the individuals have better lives, the lives that they want."
One intervention is called recovery-oriented cognitive therapy (CT-R), a hands-on, active approach that focuses on life aspirations, successful goal achievement, development of resiliency in the face of stressful symptoms and life events, all to promote positive beliefs and neutralize negative attitudes. CT-R was created by Grant, along with Aaron T. Beck, MD, an emeritus professor in the department of Psychiatry at Penn, and co-author on the study.
A June 2017 study in the journal Psychiatric Services, authored by this same team, found that CT-R is effective in individuals with schizophrenia who are functioning poorly.
The study was a follow up to a randomized clinical trial and showed that participants who received CT-R for 18 months, as compared to those who received standard treatment (e.g., anti-psychotic medications, case management), showed major improvements in daily functioning, motivation and psychotic symptoms that endured after the therapy was completed. Importantly, those with the longest course of illness showed improvement by the end of the study.
“Some of what produces the disability is related to how individuals think about the disability. And that thinking is quite changeable,” Grant said. “CT-R does indeed adjust beliefs, so that would be one of the main therapies we would suggest practitioners to implement."
The researchers called for further studies to not only replicate these findings but to also examine the clinical ratings of metacognition - higher order thinking involved in learning - and behavioral engagements when investigating the relationship between insight and cognition.
Keith Bredemeier, Aaron T. Beck, Paul M. Gran Exploring the Temporal Relationship Between Cognitive Insight and Neurocognition in Schizophrenia: A Prospective Analysis Clinical Psychological Science https://doi.org/10.1177/2167702617734019
Image: Geryon Transporting Dante and Virgil to Malasbolsas — William Blake